We rowed out on Lake Erie, Stacy
A rented boat for two
I had the ring and half the question
Then it splashed from view
We swung a borrowed net all afternoon
And every pull came up cold
The ring's still down in Lake Erie
Some things sink and some things float
You said yes, and twenty-five years on
We're still in the same boat
You said yes anyway
With a soda can tab on
Eight months you wore it proud
Till the real ring came along
That tab's still in your jewelry box
The rarest thing you've got
The ring's still down in Lake Erie
Some things sink and some things float
You said yes, and twenty-five years on
We're still in the same boat
Every anniversary
We rent that boat again
Let the lake keep its diamond
Todd made the better catch back then
Same lake where it began
The ring's still down in Lake Erie
Some things sink and some things float
You said yes, and twenty-five years on
We're still in the same boat
Stacy, I'd sink a thousand diamonds
For one more yes like that
Hold out your hand, I brought a soda
Just in case you want the tab
Let the lake keep what it's keeping
Some things sink and some things float
You said yes, and twenty-five years on
We're still in the same boat
Pass me the oars, there's more lake to go