Two thousand nine, the laundromat on Fifth Street
Your dryer stopped, I thought I knew the rules
I pulled your clothes out like a helpful stranger
Erin, I was the luckiest of fools
Got home and found it hiding in my basket
One lonely sock that wasn't mine to keep
I could have left it on the folding counter
Instead it cost me a week of sleep
Hey, I owed you something back
Hey, I had to bring it back
Your time was up
That's what I thought that day
Wrong about the dryer, right about us
The best mistake I ever made
Your time was up
Three Sundays in a row I went back there
Your sock was riding shotgun in my hand
A roll of quarters that I didn't need
Jingling like a nervous little band
I could have handed it over that first week
Could've said I think this one is yours
But one sock only buys a single Sunday
And I was after more
Hey, I owed you something back
Hey, I had to bring it back
Your time was up
That's what I thought that day
Wrong about the dryer, right about us
The best mistake I ever made
Your time was up
Now we've got a washer and a dryer
Humming down the hall, nobody waits
Still you say you miss that place on Fifth Street
The spinning and the plastic seats
I keep on finding your socks in my laundry
Like you're sneaking back into my load
One quarter sitting on the dresser
For every Sunday down the road
Keep losing socks in my basket
Keep that quarter shining bright
Erin, let the timer buzz forever
Cory's staying right here for the ride
Your time was up
That's what I thought that day
Turns out ours was just beginning
And it's never running out
Your time was up
Your time was up (time was up)