We said I do in two thousand one, Melissa
Didn't have much but a lease and a key
You took the spare from our place on Birch Street
Tied a red ribbon and hung it on the tree
Every Christmas since, you pick one little piece
Of the year we just made it through
And while the neighbors hang their matching gold
You hang the proof of me and you
Every year you hang a piece of us up there
So who made number twenty-six?
Your husband did, out in the garage
Sawdust on my sleeves and a few new tricks
You saved a bottle cap from the lake cabin weekend
Kept the stir stick when we painted the kitchen yellow
You hung the pick from the band I quit, good call
And the bobber from the only fish I ever caught, poor fellow
Then the tape measure end from the deck we built ourselves
Not a gold ball up there, not a single one to match
For years I called it our junk drawer tree
Turns out the joke was mine to catch
Every year you hang a piece of us up there
So who made number twenty-six?
Your husband did, out in the garage
Sawdust on my sleeves and a few new tricks
Twenty-five of them now, and I can tell you every year
Point at any branch and I'll take you back again
This June we finally took the old porch swing down
I saved a board and didn't say a word back then
Nights out in the garage with a saw and a plan
Cut a little wooden heart from where we used to sway
Sanded it down slow, the best a pair of hands can
And you still don't know a thing about it today
Christmas Eve, you'll head on up to bed
I'll wait until the hallway goes dark
Then hang it on a branch beside that key
The very first, right next to the newest mark
Gold balls look fine on the neighbors' tree
But ours tells the truth about us
You kept our years for twenty-five Decembers
This one's me saying I love you, that's all it does
Every year you hang a piece of us up there
So who made number twenty-six?
Your husband did, Melissa, and it's a heart
Cut from our old swing, the best of all my tricks
Who made number twenty-six?