Nineteen ninety-six, and I was only five
You held the wishbone out across to me
Three days it dried up on the kitchen windowsill
Brittle as November ever gets to be
I pulled and got the big side, made my wish
You took a pencil to the window frame
Wrote the year down small beside the glass
Thirty years now, a whole column of the same
You choke up on the short side every year
Your half breaks off a little short again
You say you never win, so you never get a wish
Mom, you always let me win
I wished for a dog, and we got Pepper
I wished to make varsity, made the team
I wished for the job out in Chicago
You came up short on every single dream
Then twenty nineteen, I finally caught on
Saw your thumb come down and snap your side
Thirty years your Haley's never lost one
Turns out you were rigging it the whole time
You choke up on the short side every year
Your half breaks off a little short again
You say you never win, so you never get a wish
Mom, you always let me win
Then I wished my own baby home and healthy
The biggest one I ever had to make
You choked up on that short side like always
And handed me the half that wouldn't break
So this year, Carol, I'm the one who'll lose
I'll grab the short side, choke up nice and tight
I'll do it just the way you taught me to
And let the long end go to you tonight
You choke up on the short side every year
Your half breaks off a little short again
You say you never win, so you never get a wish
Mom, you always let me win
Go on and pull, Mom, it's your turn
Thirty years you've had it coming
But I already know where it's going
You'll spend that wish on me
You choke up on the short side every year
You'll finally win, and I know how it'll end
You'll close your eyes and wish it all on me
Mom, you always let me win
You always let me win
Even when you win